All articles
Bad reviews

How to Reply to a 1-Star Google Review (Tradie Guide)

What to say, what to leave out, and when to take it offline.

Reply within a day or two, stay calm, own what was yours, and move it to a phone call. You are not writing for the person who is angry. You are writing for the next customer who reads it.

Who you're really writing to

One bad review won't sink you. A bad review with no answer, or an angry answer, can.

In a 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults, BrightLocal found 89% of consumers expect business owners to respond to reviews. 42% said they were unlikely to use a business that never replies. It is American data, but Australian customers read reviews the same way.

So the goal is simple. Show the next reader you are calm, fair and easy to deal with.

Before you type anything

  • Cool off. Never reply in the first hour.
  • Check your records. Were they a customer? What was the job? What went wrong?
  • Ring them first if you can. A phone call fixes more than a reply ever will.
  • Fix it because it's right, not as a trade. Google does not allow offering a discount, refund or freebie in exchange for changing or removing a review.

The four parts of a good reply

  1. Use their name and acknowledge it. A plain "thanks for letting us know" is enough.
  2. Own what you got wrong. Don't take the blame for things that were out of your hands.
  3. Say what you've done about it. One sentence.
  4. Take it offline. Give a phone number or email and ask them to get in touch.

Keep it to three or four sentences. Never mention their address, what the job cost or what you found at their place. Google's own advice is to never share a reviewer's private information or attack them personally.

Three replies you can copy

A fair complaint: you were late and didn't call.

Hi Sarah, you're right. We were late and we should have called ahead. That's not how we run jobs and I'm sorry. I've changed how we confirm arrival times. Please ring me on [number] so I can make this right. [Your name]

An unfair one: they accepted the quote, then complained about the price.

Hi Mark, thanks for the feedback. I'm sorry the price felt high. We quote in writing before we start so there are no surprises, and I'm happy to go through the invoice with you line by line. Call me on [number]. [Your name]

Someone who was never a customer.

Hi, we can't find any record of a job under this name and we'd like to look into it. Please call [number] or email [email] with the details so we can work out what happened. [Your name]

Then report that last one to Google.

When to report a review

Google only removes reviews that break its rules. A harsh review from a real customer stays up. These are the kinds that can come down:

  • Not a real experience. The person was never a customer.
  • Conflict of interest. A competitor, or a current or former employee.
  • Off-topic. A rant that has nothing to do with a job you did.

You can flag a review from your Business Profile. It may not be removed, so reply anyway. The ACCC says a business can ask the platform to remove a fake review or respond to correct the record. It also warns against trying to bury genuine negative reviews.

If you think a review is defamatory, get legal advice before you do anything else.

What not to do

  • Don't argue. No sarcasm, no point scoring.
  • Don't copy and paste. In the same BrightLocal survey, 50% of consumers were put off by generic or templated replies.
  • Don't offer money to make it go away. It breaks Google's rules.
  • Don't ignore it. Silence reads as not caring.

The takeaway

A calm, short reply with your phone number in it does more for your reputation than the bad review takes away.

ReplyMate flags every 1 to 3 star review to you the same day and never posts a reply to a bad review for you. That one should come from you.

Sources

Why your Google reviews matter more every year

Stay on the tools. We'll handle the replies.

We reply to your 4 and 5 star Google reviews and flag the rest to you the same day. No card needed to create an account.

Create your account

More from the blog